Auteurs:
Dr Silvia Valisena | HUG - Geneva University Hospitals | Switzerland
Dr Giacomo De Marco | HUG - Geneva University Hospitals | Switzerland
Dr Oscar Vazquez | HUG - Geneva University Hospitals | Switzerland
Dr Blaise Cochard | HUG - Geneva University Hospitals | Switzerland
Dr Christina Steiger | HUG - Geneva University Hospitals | Switzerland
Dr Romain Dayer | HUG - Geneva University Hospitals | Switzerland
Prof. Dimitri Ceroni | HUG - Geneva University Hospitals | Switzerland
Background: We carried out a historical narrative review of the studies on clinical and laboratory test algorithms for pediatric septic arthritis of the hip (SAH), to contextualize the Kocher and Caird criteria in their and our epoque.
Materials and Methods: The original papers by Kocher and Caird were critically appraised and their bibliography retrieved and studied. An extensive search of the literature on both the epidemiology and the clinical and laboratory criteria for SAH before and after the publication of the Kocher and Caird criteria was carried out. These studies were compared with Kocher and Caird and a historical overview was drawn.
Results: We retrieved 51 publications, including Kocher and Caird reports. By critically appraising Kocher and Caird’s studies, it emerged that their predictive criteria for SAH were originally validated in studies comparing SAH and transient synovitis of the hip (TSH) in children with a wide age range, without distinction for age subgroups. Moreover, these criteria were individuated and validated in a-priori-determined classes of patients—true SAH, presumed SAH, and true TSH—based on a joint fluid arthrocentesis (JFA) white blood cell count threshold of 50,000/mm3 and the results of JFA and blood cultures. Due to methodological differences among studies, validating Kocher and Caird criteria in different settings was not feasible. Moreover, the slow emergence of Kingella kingae in the pediatric osteoarticular infection scenario and the slow implementation of new diagnostic technologies have very likely contributed to the lack of validation of the Kocher Caird criteria, since the culture-negative cases could have been misdiagnosed and misclassified.
Conclusion: The Kocher and Caird algorithms completely ignore that clinical and biological aspects of SAH are closely related to a child's age and, above all, the pathogen responsible. They were also established in a period when the importance of Kingella kingae contribution was completely unknown. Further studies are required to define the biological markers that can unquestionably distinguish pediatric SAH (especially when due to K. kingae) and its mimics. New perspectives should be investigated by future research on the prediction rules of septic arthritis of the hip in children considering specifically the recipients’ age et the incriminated pathogens.